Jay tracks down Tim at a mental health clinic. Later, Tim tells Jay that he has some Behind-the-Scenes tapes from Marble Hornets, and they arrange to meet up and exchange them.
The first totheark video of the third season, which asks Jay if he remembers who they were.
Jay meets with Tim and gets the tapes. The first tape is shown.
A totheark video directed at Alex which claims that he caused this and will never be forgiven.
The second of Tim's tapes, which shows Alex, Brian and Tim shooting for Marble Hornets.
The third tape shows Alex and Tim location scouting at the abandoned buildings, near the hospital from Entry #51.
The last tape shows Tim after the events of the previous entry, avoiding Alex in the dark abandoned buildings.
A totheark video with a message for Tim about who he can trust.
Jay meets with Tim in order to take a look at the buildings from his tapes, but Tim is on edge about his role in this.
Jay and Tim meet again, only for Tim to reveal that he knows about the Marble Hornets channel.
A totheark video displaying audio from the previous entry with the message "TRUTH WITH LIGHT".
Jay goes to the maintenance tunnel from Entry #58 to find more information about Alex's location.
Jay goes over Tim's medical records that he found in the previous entry.
A totheark video of someone spying on Tim through his window.
Today you have to promise yourself something. No matter what is going on in your life, no matter how difficult things can be, promise to give 100% of your self every waking minute. It is really easy to just sit down for an afternoon and get nothing done, or spend too much time worrying and not doing anything about it. Make this promise to yourself!
Jay goes to find Tim in Rosswood Park and is confronted by his second personality.
Totheark video with very ominous messages.
Jay and Tim meet again and decide to work together to find Alex.
Jay and Tim go to the building from Entry #52 and further explore Rosswood Park.
Totheark video with messages that appears to relate to the previous entry.
After Entry #64, Tim goes back to the abandoned hospital and begins to completely break down.
Totheark video with many televisions in a forest displaying clips from previous entries.
Tim takes Jay back to the abandoned hospital and reveals that he used to be a patient there, and that he could be the cause of everything.
The tape that Jay took in the previous entry is shown.
Jay and Tim leave their current location in order to hide from Alex.
The video "68" is uploaded to the channel, which Jay takes down and re-uploads.
Totheark video with messages about their current state of mind.
Jay and Tim revisit the red tower to find old tapes Alex had already begun burning.
The first burned tape shows footage from near the start of Marble Hornets' production.
The next tape shows Alex giving Jay the tapes from filming Marble Hornets.
Jay and Tim go to Alex's old house in search of anything useful. Jay begins to see The Operator.
Totheark hacks the channel again.
Jay has gotten better nearly two months after Entry #72, and Tim believes he knows why.
Totheark video that asks the question "Who are the liars" - "Are you one of them" - "Are you both of them".
Jay and Tim try to follow Alex's trail.
The tape that Jay stole reveals what happened to Jessica.
Totheark video with messages correlating to the previous few entries.
After finding the message in "File", Jay goes to confront Tim with a knife.
The hooded person pays Jay a visit.
Jay goes to Benedict Hall for clues, but is visited by Tim and the hooded person.
Clips of Benedict Hall in a totheark video which bears the question "Who am I" - "Am I the third".
Jay goes back to Benedict Hall only to be greeted with a life-threatening discovery.
Tim shows his perspective of visiting Benedict Hall.
Tim finds footage on Jay's laptop of events that happened to Jay prior to Entry #77.
The final totheark video which asks distorted questions for Tim.
Tim confronts the hooded man at Benedict Hall and learns the truth about Jay's fate.
Tim finds a tape that reveals a disturbing truth about Brian.
Tim waits for Alex to bring the confrontation to him.
Tim goes to confront both Alex and The Operator in order to finish this nightmare.
After Alex's death, Tim throws away his mask and visits Jessica, and claims Jay has moved away.